This week’s experiment focused on the transfer of heat. When an object is heated up the molecules begin to vibrate faster and faster causing a rise in temperature and the heat is transferred through conduction, convection, or radiation. Conduction is the transfer of heat from a region of higher temperature to a region of low temperature by being transferred from molecule to molecule (Tillery, Enger & Ross, 2008). The second way to transfer heat is by convection which is the transfer of heat by movement of the warm matter (Laureate Education Inc, 2010). The third way to transfer heat is by radiation which is the transfer of heat through an empty space (Laureate Education Inc, 2010). All three of these methods of heat transfer were seen in this experiment. One of the materials I used was plastic wrap which allowed me to see what was happening inside the cup. After thirty minutes water vapor had condensed on the plastic wrap and was dripping down into the cup. When a liquid is heated it warms, expands, and evaporates. When the water vapor reached the material it came in contact with the cooler air causing the water vapor to cool and condense. When the water cools it falls thus creating a convection current inside the cup. Convection currents play a big part in the way the water was cooled down. By creating the current it allowed cooler molecules to return to the warm water cooling the molecules down faster. For another material I used tin foil which created an environment where conduction occurred. Using this material created an environment where the molecules did not have to move to transfer the heat after a certain period of time. The heat from the water and air trapped under the tin foil allows all the molecules inside as well as in the tin foil to heat up to a constant temperature. This keeps the water and air inside at a constant temperature which slows down the cooling process. Radiant heat transfer was also seen with this material because the heat could be felt when your hand was held over the cup.
When I do this experiment again I would like to use materials that are more commonly used with keeping things warm. I would hold a class discussion for these common items and bring what them to class. These items can include Styrofoam cups, tin foil, plastic and glass containers. I think the Styrofoam cup would be the best insulator because it keeps hot liquid from burning your hand however, it would depend on what kind of lid was used. Overall, I still think tinfoil would be the best insulator. Different kinds of food also need to be kept warm so I would discuss with the class the most common foods they eat and home that need to be kept warm. This could include soup, hot dogs, noodles, or macaroni and cheese. I think these types of foods would act the same as the water except the more surface area the food has the faster the food will cool down. By including the students in the experiment set up they will make real life connections with the activity as well as the concepts and ideas being put to the test. By completing this experiment I would want my students to understand what the different types of heat transfer are, what a good insulator is, and how it connects to their everyday lives. This experiment is focused on an idea that students can use every day at home when making their food or even for safety when using hot liquids.
I am concerned that you might have the idea of heat conduction backwards. Metals have a very high heat conduction value, meaning they allow heat to pass through them quickly. Aluminum is one of the highest metals, and therefore will be a very poor insulator of heat. Even though the molecules are allowed to stay inside, the energy from those molecules is easily accepted and transmitted by the metal, and will cool down the fluid faster. That is why we use aluminum foil in the oven, since it can contain the food and allow all the heat to pass through, saving us money on energy costs.
ReplyDeleteI like your ideas of involving the students in real world applications. This is so important to help the students "buy into" the idea that the activity is worthwhile and relevant.
ReplyDelete