Overall everything with the experiment went well. My biggest challenge was figuring out how I was going to get from the question to the results that would answer the question. But, through trial and error I figured out what I needed to do to get the results. To get a different result for this activity I would have students choose to test if the length of the string affects the stop time or the amplitude from which the pendulum is dropped affects the stop time.
I would set the same experiment up for my students because they were already curious and asking questions about the experiment. I would have my students complete the same test, will weight affect the stop time of the pendulum, and then add an extra experiments on how amplitude and the length of the sting affects stop time. This experiment is relevant to my student’s lives because they are always out playing on the swings. After completing the experiment inside with the pendulum, I would take my students outside and see if they get the same results on a swing.
From completing this experiment I would like my students to better understand the concepts we have studied in class. They will get to see how Newton’s Laws and air resistance (friction) affect a pendulum and then later a person on a swing. This experiment will also provide a good teachable moment to introduce the concept of momentum. If and when I do this experiment with my class I feel it will be very successful. It allows students to review past concepts and ideas and test to see how they affect different objects.
Jessica
ReplyDeleteI did the same experiment, with pendulums and mass, but I had the opposite results. I really like the sound of your experiment, especially with the use of the photo gate and the timer. I would be willing to bet that your results were more accurate, but I am still not entirely certain. Does air resistance have more affect than momentum? Why would my smaller mass pendulum come to a stop faster for five separate trials, if the larger mass pendulum SHOULD stop sooner? Any insight?
When I originally did the experiment I was thinking along the same lines as you. I thought for sure the heavier pendulums would swing longer then the lighter ones and when I did not get the data to support that I was really surprised. How I figured it worked was the force that gravity puts on an object would be greater on a heavier object then a lighter object. Also, an object that has greater mass requires more force to oppose friction, or in this case air resistance. I think of it as pushing a sixth grader on a swing. It takes a lot harder push to keep the student swinging then it does to keep a kindergartner swinging at the same height. Since there was not a continuous push on the pendulum it slowed down faster. I plan on doing this experiment again with my students and will post the results after.
Delete